CO-CREATION, PUBLIC VALUE AND THE DISTRIBUTION OF AUTHORITY



An invitation to produce a useful solution is not equivalent to an invitation to exercise democratic power. The distinction matters because the contemporary rhetoric of co-creation often makes collaboration appear intrinsically inclusive: residents, professionals, companies, researchers and public officials meet around a shared problem, mobilise different competences and arrive at an innovative result. Yet neither the problem nor the criteria of usefulness need have been collectively established. Lund identifies the decisive historical shift. Earlier participation debates, shaped by demands for empowerment and equitable influence, measured democratic quality through the relation between rights and decision-making. A newer language of co-creation increasingly measures the legitimacy of public action through problem-solving capacity, creativity and delivered value. The shift is not a clean replacement; deliberation and empowerment remain possible within co-created programmes. Its danger is more subtle. 


If knowledge and competence rather than political standing become the primary reasons for admitting participants, those best equipped to contribute to a predefined solution may be mistaken for those entitled to determine the problem. Lund's tripartite distinction between co-implementers, co-designers and co-initiators clarifies what the universal term 'participant' obscures. The person who supplies a report enabling a service to work has a different kind of influence from the person who helps determine the service's design; the person who initiates the issue and negotiates recognition by an authority occupies a different position again. None of these positions is intrinsically democratic. An initiative led from below may reproduce the exclusions of an expert group; a programme initiated from above may enable consequential influence if participants possess enforceable room to revise the brief. The question cannot be settled by celebrating autonomy or condemning institutions in advance. It requires a record of who proposed the initial problem, whose knowledge was regarded as relevant, what could actually be changed, how conflicts were handled and what happened after an intervention was completed. Leino and Puumala's Finnish cases expose the passage between the production of knowledge and its institutional uptake. A municipality can support an open meeting and still retain the power to decide which proposals count as administratively credible. Participants with scarce time, unfamiliarity with planning language or weak political networks may be formally invited but materially disadvantaged. Säumel and colleagues' urban food laboratories add a territorial dimension: the continued use of a communal garden depends on access to land, finance, labour and municipal recognition. The promise of co-creation is tested not only during the event but after a project's funding has ceased, when temporary collaboration either becomes a durable public capacity or disappears. Even an apparently successful garden may privilege residents with the time and resources to cultivate it, while project-specific indicators conceal the unrepresented. The methodological implication is that participation must be followed across its different temporal states, including preparation, invitation, negotiation, authorship, maintenance and institutional response. A project report that registers workshop attendance but not the fate of proposals documents an event rather than the democratic consequence of that event. Rojas-Pernia and colleagues' inclusive museum projects make the distinction tangible at another scale: creative expression and learning can widen the available forms of participation, but their public significance also depends on institutional mediation, the conditions of accessibility and whether the organisation changes its continuing practices. Nor can participatory design be assessed solely by counting new features. A modification to an interface may be useful while its users remain unable to challenge the categories through which the institution represents them. In each case, practical usefulness matters, but it does not replace an account of authority; a technically successful solution to the wrong collectively defined problem may be both innovative and undemocratic. The aim is not to oppose outcomes to procedures but to prevent achievement on one dimension from silently certifying achievement on the other.


The same confusion becomes consequential when collaboration is translated into contracts, metadata, classificatory schemes and public evidence. Gui, Song and Xia separate responsibility, profit, risk and accountability in urban sewage-treatment partnerships and examine how administrative efficiency modifies their relationship with reported performance. Sharma's outsourcing typology likewise distinguishes forms of public-private work by the nature of the task and the intensity of management and organisational relationships. Both studies make it difficult to speak of partnership as one homogeneous arrangement. Yet neither the distribution of contractual roles nor a positive performance indicator establishes who has the practical ability to demand a correction when a service fails. An authority can allocate operational tasks to external organisations while retaining final powers over standards, investment and acceptable risk. Citizens may then be asked to contribute information about failure without receiving the capacity to alter the rule that produced it. What looks like the co-production of a public good can be a highly unequal distribution of evidentiary and corrective labour. Lund's account of stewardship, mediation and catalysis becomes useful here if these are read as obligations to maintain the integrity of collaboration, negotiate irreducible conflict and enable initiatives rather than managerial personalities or neutral gestures. Stewardship has to be examined through records: who controlled the agenda, financed participation, compensated time, decided what evidence entered the final account and remained answerable when expectations were not met? The archival analogue is equally exacting. Contaxis and colleagues describe the practical infrastructure of discoverability: reliable descriptions, persistent identifiers, related resources and differentiated access conditions. Levchenko and colleagues show how Europe PMC relates preprints, metadata and later publication states without rendering those states identical. Their methods can make a collaborative contribution more visible, but visibility is not the same as editorial power. A contributor may be credited in a searchable record while losing the ability to dispute an interpretation, withdraw sensitive detail or correct the attribution of a decision. A DOI identifies a record; it does not independently guarantee that the categories assigned to that record are adequate, fair or approved by everyone concerned. Blanke's counter-archiving strengthens the point by showing how new arrangements of existing evidence can recover perspectives suppressed by inherited classifications, while each rearrangement introduces its own decisions about inclusion and relevance. Here co-creation can no longer be treated as a stage before documentation. It extends into the production of the archive's public grammar: the selection of an observation, the naming of an actor, the preservation of disagreement, the disclosure of a change and the authority to amend a representation. This is particularly important for an extensive conceptual corpus whose internal links can proliferate faster than its differences are justified. For Socioplastics, terms such as participation, mediation, stewardship, openness and innovation are insufficient unless they identify a passage that can be inspected in practice. Recording an encounter does not demonstrate shared control over its outcome; inclusive co-design becomes consequential when participants can initiate, refuse or revise decisions. Maintaining a participatory environment differs from holding authority over its final interpretation. Likewise, receiving a complaint must be distinguished from issuing a consequential response, and actual restitution from symbolic acknowledgement. Legal instruments governing reparations cannot simply be extended beyond their defined scope. Conceptual proximity alone does not establish that these operations have been demonstrated. Their coherence would emerge through complementary questions applied to one situated case: who is entitled to enter, who sets the problem, who can generate an alternative, who bears the cost of articulation, whose version becomes archived, how is disagreement preserved, and which institution must answer when the eventual outcome fails? The same test could be applied to a municipal living lab, a participatory museum programme, a contracted water service or a neighbourhood climate consultation, but the evidence cannot be flattened into one score. A survey, a contract, a co-designed artefact and a claim for repair hold different kinds of authority and demand different procedures of verification. An effective research archive would record their connections without pretending that interoperability has made them interchangeable. What must remain visible is the asymmetry between the public institutions that commission, classify and approve and the people whose participation supplies knowledge, legitimacy and sometimes unpaid work. The object of inquiry is therefore not whether an initiative describes itself as collaborative but whether the distribution of authority changes and remains open to scrutiny when collaboration becomes a decision, an infrastructure and an enduring record. The enduring analytical object is the fragmentation and unequal distribution of authority across collaboration, institutional decisions and public records.



Anto Lloveras works across architecture, urbanism and the epistemology of spatial research. Through LAPIEZA LAB he examines how collective encounters become evidence, documentary classifications and decisions, with particular attention to public authority and the institutional conditions of participation.